WE'RE AVAILABLE (09) 486 4710 I Email

Pedersens News

Email me when new posts are made to this blog

Tenancy Tribunal wrecking ball decisions smashed unsuspecting Landlord

By David Faulkner
October 12th, 2017.

On the 27th April 2017 at the Tenancy Tribunal in Dunedin, adjudicator Wilson made a ruling on a case that has sent alarm bells ringing and many think the ruling was grossly unfair.

The former tenant Natalie Parry lodged a claim for a refund of rent after she found out that the property she was renting was not fully compliant. The landlord, Vic Inglis was oblivious that there was anything wrong. The property in question was personal and precious to the landlord. It had been the family home for 10 years. The property was in very good condition and the adjudicator acknowledges that the landlord made no attempt to avert Council laws or to exploit the tenants.

The problem arose when the tenant became aware that the downstairs part of the premises did not have a permit for the work undertaken to convert the space into living quarters.

Blog 1-407
Vic Inglis probably hasn't been feeling great about being a landlord after a very tough decision went against him. (Photo courtesy of Otago Daily TImes)

What made the matter worse for the landlord was that the tenant only became aware of the issue when she sublet the downstairs part of the property without consent from the landlord. Mr Inglis was completely unaware that the downstairs did not have council consent as he had not got a LIM report (Land Information Memorandum) when he purchased the property over a decade ago. This was the only mistake he made but what a costly mistake to make.

In a case that seems grossly unfair, a landlord had rented a property that was in a perfectly good condition to a tenant who had breached her agreement yet not only did she get nearly $11,000 in refunded rent, she pocketed over $3,000 from subletting the property without the consent of the landlord.
 

Is Tenancy Tribunal Like Playing Russian Roulette?

 At Real iQ, we have examined this decision closely and have obtained the case notes. We are aware that Mr Inglis has appealed to the District Court so the decision may yet be overturned. However, we feel it is important to understand how the adjudicator came to this incredible decision and we also again provide evidence that going to Tenancy Tribunal can be like playing Russian Roulette.

Let’s analyse Adjudicator Wilson’s decision.

1.     Was the Tenancy Illegal?

This is what Wilson believes. Yes, the downstairs did not have a permit but does that make the entire property illegal?

The section adjudicator Wilson refers to in the Residential Tenancies Act is section 137; Prohibited Transactions. This eludes to the fact that you cannot enter into a contract that contravenes the provisions of the Residential Tenancies Act and that any money paid under the contract is recoverable to the tenant.

2.       But was there anything actually wrong with the property?

The answer to that is no. After finding out that the downstairs did not have consent Mr Inglis approached the council and was able to obtain a Certificate of Acceptance which then made the property fully compliant. No additional work was done.

Yet Wilson states that the Code of Acceptance does not retrospectively make the tenancy lawful because the consent was not issued until two months after the tenancy ended. Therefore, in the eyes of Wilson, this was an illegal tenancy.

3.     The Landlord’s Cross-Application Is Out of Here!

  Mr Inglis made a cross-application against the tenant due to damage to chattels and for the removal of smoke alarms which has maximum exemplary damages of $3,000.

This was thrown out as the decision that the tenancy was unlawful meant that Tribunal had no jurisdiction to consider any of the landlord’s claims. Basically, the tenant could have been operating a Meth Lab and the landlord had no power to do anything about it.

4.     Grounds for a Rehearing? No chance!

 Unsurprisingly, the decision did not sit well with Mr Inglis who immediately applied for a rehearing. However, there were no grounds for this. Section 105 of the Residential Tenancies Act refers to Rehearings.

You can only seek a rehearing on the ground that a substantial wrong or miscarriage of justice has or may have occurred. In the opinion of the adjudicator, this has not happened on this occasion. This is a matter for a District Court if the landlord chooses to appeal.

5.     Different Adjudicator, Different Ruling

 Meanwhile, in Christchurch, a landlord appeared to get off lightly in comparison with Mr Inglis.

The case between Danielle Williamson v Green Gift Health and Wealth Ltd highlights the inconsistencies that plague Tribunal.

On the 31st July 2017, Adjudicator Armstrong chose not to refund rent even though the property that was tenanted had a second bathroom without consent and a wood burner not compliant with the Building Code.

In this case, Ms Williamson took Green Gift Health and Wealth Ltd to Tenancy Tribunal seeking compensation due to the poor condition of the property they had rented and the fact that parts of the property were non-compliant. Adjudicator Armstrong ruled in favour of the tenant yet did not refund any rent.

This makes the Inglis decision seem very unfair as in the Christchurch case, the landlord clearly breached and would have been aware of the poor condition of the property. The property was not only non-compliant but also a health risk to the tenants yet the tenant was ordered to pay rent arrears to the landlord.

Be Consistent and Be Fair

 The greatest frustration we hear about from Property Managers is how inconsistent Tribunal can be. In defence to many adjudicators, we have no doubt that many Property Managers attend unprepared and have limited knowledge of the act.

However, our research does show that too often we get inconsistencies. One of our aims is to hold Tribunal accountable to their decision and to educate Property Managers so they are better prepared when attending Tribunal.

The question this case highlights though is how many illegal tenancies are there, and does this give the green flag for tenants to seek thousands of dollars in rent refunds as many rental properties could have similar issues?

Our advice to Property Managers is to ensure that the landlord is fully aware of the obligations to provide the property compliant with all legislation and if you suspect that a property may not be compliant, raise the question with your landlord and highlight this Tribunal case.

Originally published on realiq.nz

3 Comments

fatihin nurul says ...
ui hal ini, saya tidak memanggilnya untuk tidak menyiagen astm a283 c
agen pipa boiler
agen plat abrex 400
agen plat asme516 grade70
agen plat astm a285 c
agen plat astm516 70
agen plat boiler
agen plat hardox
agen plat hb 400
agen plat high strenght
agen plat high tensile sm490 yb
agen plat high tensile sm490ya
agen plat kapal
agen plat stainless ss304
agen plat stainless ss310
agen plat stainless ss316
agen plat sumihard
agen round bar besi aisi 440s45c
agen round bar scm440
agen steel rail
agen steel sheet pile
distributor astm a283 c
distributor pipa boiler
distributor plat abrex 400
distributor plat asme516 grade70
distributor plat astm a285 c
distributor plat astm516 70
distributor plat boiler
distributor plat hb 400
distributor plat high strenght
distributor plat high tensile sm490 yb
distributor plat high tensile sm490ya
distributor plat kapal
distributor plat stainless ss304
distributor plat stainless ss310
distributor plat stainless ss316
distributor plat sumihard
Supplier sch 40
Supplier sch 40
Supplier Plat kapal besi baja bki krakatau steel
Supplier besi beton Sni Ulir Polos
undangan pernikahan ala jepang
Pabrik Besi Pipa Baja Schedule 40
Toko Besi Unp Baja
Supplier besi wf
Toko sch 40
Toko sch 40
Supplier besi siku
Supplier besi wf baja
undangan pernikahan islami
Pabrik Pipa Besi Hitam Medium
Jual Besi Unp Baja
Toko besi wf
Distributor besi beton Sni Ulir Polos polos ulir
Agen sch 40
Agen sch 40
Supplier pipa besi baja sch 40 sch 80
Supplier besi unp
undangan pernikahan ada fotonya
Pabrik Besi Wf
Harga Besi Unp Baja
Agen besi wf
Distributor besi beton sii
Pabrik sch 40
Pabrik sch 40
Supplier Plat besi
Supplier besi siku
undangan pernikahan ala india
Pabrik Besi H beam
Pabrik Besi Unp Baja
Pabrik besi wf
Distributor besi beton psi Ulir Polos
Distributor besi Pipa sch 80 baja
Distributor besi Pipa sch 80 baja
Supplier besi h beam
Supplier Plat besi plat kapal
Pabrik Besi Beton
Distributor Besi Cnp Baja
Distributor Besi Beton
Distributor besi beton perwira
Harga besi Pipa sch 80 baja
Harga besi Pipa sch 80 baja
Supplier besi wf
Supplier besi h beam baja
undangan pernikahan simple
www.sentrabesibaja.com
Supplier Besi Cnp Baja
Harga Besi Beton
Distributor besi beton PAS
Jual besi Pipa sch 80 baja
Jual besi Pipa sch 80 baja
Supplier wiremesh
Supplier besi cnp
undangan pernikahan bermanfaat
Distributor Welded Beam T beam King Queen Cross Castellated Beam
Agen Besi Cnp Baja
Jual Besi Beton
Distributor besi beton master steel ms
Supplier besi Pipa sch 80 baja
Supplier besi Pipa sch 80 baja
Supplier besi unp
www.gudangbesibaja.com
undangan pernikahan islami
Distributor Bondek Cor
Toko Besi Cnp Baja
Supplier Besi Beton
Distributor besi beton ksty
Toko besi Pipa sch 80 baja
Toko besi Pipa sch 80 baja
Supplier besi cnp
Pabrik besi Wf Baja
undangan pernikahan amplop surat
Distributor Atap Spandek Sni
Jual Besi Cnp Baja
Toko Besi Beton
Distributor besi beton krakatau steel
Agen besi Pipa sch 80 baja
Agen besi Pipa sch 80 baja
Supplier besi hollow
Pabrik bondek
undangan pernikahan bentuk dompet
Distributor Plat Bordes Kembang
Harga Besi Cnp Baja
Agen Besi Beton
Distributor besi beton jcac
Pabrik besi Pipa sch 80 baja
Pabrik besi Pipa sch 80 baja
Supplier besi beton Sni Ulir Polos
Pabrik wiremesh
undangan pernikahan chinese
Distributor Plat Besi Hitam
Pabrik Besi Cnp Baja
Pabrik Besi Beton
Distributor besi beton interworld steel is
Distributor Plat Bordes
Distributor Plat Bordes
ironsteelcenter.com
Pabrik pipa besi baja sch 40 sch 80
undangan pernikahan lucu
Distributor Plat Kapal Bki Krakatau Steel
Distributor Besi Hollow Baja
Distributor besi hollow
Distributor besi beton gunung garuda
Harga Plat Bordes
Harga Plat Bordes
Pabrik stainless steel
Pabrik besi hollow
undangan pernikahan bagus
Distributor Jual Besi Siku Baja
Supplier Besi Hollow Baja
Harga besi hollow
Distributor besi beton delcoprima
Jual Plat Bordes
Jual Plat Bordes
Pabrik atap spandek
Pabrik besi beton Sni Ulir Polos
undangan pernikahan bahasa inggris islam
Distributor Besi Unp Baja Profil Kanal
Agen Besi Hollow Baja
Jual besi hollow
Distributor besi beton cakra steel cs
Supplier Plat Bordes
Supplier Plat Bordes
Pabrik baja ringan
Pabrik besi wf baja
undangan pernikahan contoh
Distributor Besi Cnp Profil Baja Gording
Toko Besi Hollow Baja
Supplier besi hollow
Distributor besi beton bjku
Jual Jaket Parka Jual Jaket Parka
Jaket Parka Jaket Parka
undangan pernikahan kalender
undangan pernikahan bahasa inggris islam
undangan pernikahan islami
undangan pernikahan unik dan murah
undangan pernikahan modern
undangan pernikahan online
undangan pernikahan
undangan pernikahan amplop surat
undangan pernikahan simple
undangan pernikahan murah
undangan pernikahan unik
undangan pernikahan artis
undangan pernikahan modern
undangan pernikahan artis
undangan pernikahan arab
undangan pernikahan
undangan pernikahan
LINK 6
Steven Angelina says ...
That is a good write-up When i viewed on account of write about the item. Really it is what exactly I need to to discover trust with foreseeable future you might go on intended for giving a really fantastic write-up. Crawley Accountants
Rumi says ...
Cool stuff you have and you keep overhaul every one of us]
Essay writing service with 100% satisfaction guarantee and unlimited revisions. Now you can avail 30% flat discount with all orders offered by MHR Writer!
Thinking about switching providers?

NO OBLIGATION DISCUSSION AND ADVICE AROUND YOUR CURRENT OR FUTURE RENTAL 
INVESTMENTS.